Mac App Store vs Homebrew: which to choose in 2026?

Mac App Store: what is it?

The Mac App Store is Apple's official store for macOS, launched on January 6, 2011 with Mac OS X 10.6.6 Snow Leopard. It now hosts roughly 30,000 applications, all subjected to Apple's review process, signed with a developer certificate, and run inside a sandbox introduced in 2012 that restricts system access.

For whom?

The Mac App Store targets mainstream users: anyone who wants to install an app in two clicks, without Terminal, without managing signatures, with a single Apple ID for sharing purchases across family devices. It's the default option for anyone coming from iPhone or iPad.

Strengths

• Maximum security: mandatory Apple review, systematic notarized signing, strict sandbox.
• Automatic updates via the system, no intervention required.
• Payment handled by Apple: Apple Pay, automatic refunds, family sharing.
• Clean uninstallation: drag-and-drop to Trash is enough, minimal system residues.
• No Terminal required, accessible to non-technical users.

Limitations

• Sandbox blocks system access: no Accessibility API, no powerful global shortcuts, no system menu bar customization.
• No advanced menu-bar apps: Raycast, BetterTouchTool, Karabiner-Elements, NotchIA, AltTab — all ineligible.
• Apple commission 15–30%: some vendors prefer direct sales to preserve their margin.
• Slow Apple review: updates sometimes blocked for days.
• Limited catalog: ~30,000 apps vs. hundreds of thousands available outside the store.

Homebrew: what is it?

Homebrew is an open-source package manager for macOS and Linux, created in 2009 by Max Howell. It runs from the command line via the brew command and offers two catalogs: formulae (CLI tools: git, node, python, ffmpeg) and casks (GUI apps: Chrome, VS Code, Slack, Docker). In 2026, roughly 7,000 casks and 7,000 formulae are available, maintained by thousands of contributors on GitHub.

For whom?

Homebrew targets power users, developers, sysadmins and anyone comfortable with Terminal. It's the de facto standard for setting up a developer Mac in minutes via a reproducible Brewfile script.

Strengths

• Full freedom: access to apps outside the store (Raycast, NotchIA, Karabiner-Elements, Hammerspoon).
• Scriptable installation: a Brewfile installs 50 apps in a single command, reproducible on any Mac.
• CLI tools: git, node, python, postgresql, redis — the foundation of a developer workstation.
• Bulk updates: brew upgrade updates everything at once.
• No Apple account required for downloads.
• Open-source and auditable: every formula and cask is a Ruby file viewable on GitHub.

Limitations

• Requires Terminal: entry barrier for non-technical users.
• Trust in the maintainer: each cask points to the vendor's server, no Apple review layer.
• No built-in payments: purchases handled directly by the vendor (Paddle, Stripe, Gumroad).
• Manual uninstall sometimes needed via brew uninstall --zap to clean Application Support files.
• No sandbox: an app installed via brew runs with user privileges, no isolation.

Side-by-side comparison on 10 criteria

When to choose the Mac App Store

The Mac App Store is the right call in these situations:

• Apps that don't need advanced system access: Things 3, Pages, Numbers, Pixelmator Pro, 1Password (the App Store version).
• Family Sharing: one purchase shared across up to 5 members.
• Native iCloud sync: apps that plug into iCloud Drive without configuration.
• Managed corporate Mac: MDM can whitelist the App Store to control what employees install.
• Non-technical users: a relative who will never touch Terminal.

In 2026, vendors like Cultured Code (Things 3), Pixelmator Team, and Omni Group still distribute exclusively via the Mac App Store for user simplicity and Family Sharing.

When to choose Homebrew

Homebrew becomes essential as soon as you hit one of these situations:

• Setting up a developer Mac: Node, Python, Postgres, Docker, Git — all installable in minutes.
• Advanced menu-bar apps: Raycast, BetterTouchTool, Karabiner-Elements, Hammerspoon, NotchIA.
• Apps requiring the Accessibility API: automation, global system shortcuts, click simulation.
• Reproducibility: a Brewfile versioned in Git lets you rebuild a fresh Mac in 15 minutes.
• Vendors who refuse Apple's commission: Sublime Text, JetBrains IDEs, Sketch (direct distribution).
• CLI tools impossible on the App Store: ffmpeg, yt-dlp, rsync, htop, jq.

Apps available only through Homebrew

Some iconic Mac apps have never been on the Mac App Store, because of sandbox constraints:

Other notable examples:

• Raycast — universal launcher, Accessibility for its system commands.
• Karabiner-Elements — low-level keyboard remapping, kernel extension.
• Hammerspoon — Lua automation, full system access.
• Rectangle — window management, Accessibility access.
• AltTab — Windows-style window switcher.
• BetterTouchTool — Touch Bar and trackpad customization.
• iTerm2 — advanced terminal, extended shell hooks.

Note: Raycast started exclusively outside the store in 2020. Several apps follow the same path — Homebrew distribution first, eventually a "lite" App Store version.

How to install Homebrew

A single command to paste in Terminal:

/bin/bash -c "$(curl -fsSL https://raw.githubusercontent.com/Homebrew/install/HEAD/install.sh)"

The script downloads Homebrew, installs Xcode Command Line Tools if needed, and configures PATH. Duration: 2 to 5 minutes depending on your connection. No reboot required. Verify:

brew --version
# Homebrew 4.x.x

First use, for example installing NotchIA:

brew install --cask coaxel2/notchia/notchia

To compare or pick another install method, see NotchIA install methods.

Verdict: complementary, not competitors

The classic trap is framing Mac App Store vs Homebrew as a binary choice. They are two different tools for two different types of apps:

• Mac App Store for consumer apps that don't need deep system access (Things 3, 1Password, Pages, Pixelmator Pro).
• Homebrew for apps that require the Accessibility API, CLI dev tools, and reproducibility through a Brewfile.

A typical macOS power-user setup in 2026 combines both: App Store for 5 to 10 signed and iCloud-synced apps, Homebrew for 30 to 50 CLI tools + 10 to 15 GUI casks. No conflict, no interference.

FAQ: Mac App Store vs Homebrew

Is Homebrew safe?

Homebrew is broadly safe: open-source project active since 2009, large contributor base, auditable code on GitHub. The risk lies in individual casks — each cask points to the vendor's server, without Apple's review layer. Recommendation: only install casks from known vendors and inspect the command before running it. Homebrew itself has required no root privileges since 2020.

Can I use the Mac App Store and Homebrew together?

Yes, and most power users do. The two systems coexist without conflict: Mac App Store for consumer and iCloud-native apps (Pages, Things 3, 1Password), Homebrew for CLI tools and apps that need system access (Raycast, NotchIA, Karabiner-Elements). No interference on updates or file management.

Do I need a Mac App Store account to use Homebrew apps?

No. Homebrew downloads directly from vendor servers, never through Apple ID. No account required. That's one of its major use cases: quickly install Chrome, VS Code, or Docker on a new machine without even signing into an Apple account.

Why aren't some apps like NotchIA on the Mac App Store?

The Mac App Store enforces a strict sandbox that blocks access to the Accessibility API, global system shortcuts, and advanced Now Playing integrations. Any advanced menu-bar app (Raycast, BetterTouchTool, Karabiner-Elements, NotchIA, AltTab) must therefore be distributed outside the store via Homebrew or direct DMG.

How do I install Homebrew?

Open Terminal and paste: /bin/bash -c "$(curl -fsSL https://raw.githubusercontent.com/Homebrew/install/HEAD/install.sh)". The install takes 2 to 5 minutes. No reboot required. Verify with brew --version.

Does Homebrew slow down the Mac?

No. Homebrew is inactive when not in use. No background daemon, no launch agent. Apps installed via brew run exactly as if they were downloaded as a DMG.

← Back to home