Boring Notch vs NotchIA: an honest 2026 comparison

Context: why two apps for the notch?

Since the notch arrived on the 14" and 16" MacBook Pro in 2021, then on the MacBook Air in 2024, a new category of macOS apps emerged: notch utilities. Their goal: turn that black bar — initially seen as a design constraint — into a useful interactive surface.

Two projects dominate the category today: Boring Notch, distributed for free on GitHub, and NotchIA, an independent proprietary app. Both are written in Swift / SwiftUI, run on Apple Silicon and target macOS 15 or later. But their philosophy, release cadence and feature scope diverge significantly.

This comparison was written by Axel Courty, creator of NotchIA. I'll flag my bias up front: I know NotchIA from the inside, and I do not have access to Boring Notch's private code (it is public, but I do not contribute to it). I tested Boring Notch on my MacBook Pro M3 14" for two weeks before writing this. All claims about Boring Notch below are verifiable on its official GitHub repository.

Boring Notch in a nutshell

NotchIA in a nutshell

Comparison table (10 criteria)

This table does not say one app is better than the other — it lists the axes where they diverge. The deciding factor depends on your personal priorities: price, open-source code, feature scope, language, AI integration.

When to choose Boring Notch

Boring Notch is the right pick in several typical cases:

• You want 100% free, no subscription, no purchase. No Pro tier, no paywall: everything is included from install.
• You value open-source on principle. The source is public, auditable, forkable. You can contribute, file bugs, read the exact logic of each module.
• Your needs map to the basic modules. Media, calendar, AirDrop, pomodoro, battery: that's precisely what Boring Notch covers cleanly.
• You're comfortable in English. The UI and documentation are English-only; no native i18n today.
• You want to participate in a community project. If you have time to give as a Swift contributor, it's a great entry point.

Boring Notch is a serious project, and its GitHub success reflects real usefulness. Choosing it is never a bad choice — just a different one.

When to choose NotchIA

NotchIA fits better in these cases:

• You want live AI in the notch. NotchIA is currently the only macOS notch app that surfaces the real-time status of Claude Code, ChatGPT Codex and GitHub Copilot, with 10 states (Compiling, Terminal, Searching, Reading, Writing, etc.) and explicit token consumption. If you code daily with Claude Code or Codex, this integration reshapes your terminal workflow.
• You want on-device Apple Intelligence. The Digest module (exclusive to 2.8.0) consumes your RSS feeds and produces a summary via Apple Intelligence local models, 100% on-device, no third-party server traffic.
• You want polished UX and a planned release cycle. A single person owns the roadmap, enforces a consistent design and ships regular releases (2.8.0 dropped May 15, 2026, 6 months after 2.7).
• You use macOS in French, Spanish or German. NotchIA is localized in 4 languages, which materially changes the experience for non-English speakers.
• You want direct support. An email to notchia.app@gmail.com gets a reply from Axel, the developer — not a bot, not a tiered ticket system.
• You want a one-time purchase. €24.99 once unlocks every Pro feature forever, updates included. No mandatory subscription.

Verdict: not competitors, complementary

The two apps don't target exactly the same audience. Boring Notch is an excellent free entry point into the notch utility category, backed by an open-source community. NotchIA is an independent proprietary app that bets on exclusive integrations (live AI, Apple Intelligence) and editor-grade polish, funded by a freemium model.

If you're a Swift developer and open-source fan, Boring Notch is probably your first install. If you code with Claude Code or ChatGPT Codex and want polished UX (in French, Spanish or German if needed), NotchIA is more likely to stick. And if you can't decide: install Boring Notch first (free), then test NotchIA Essential (also free). Two weeks tell you which fits your actual usage.

The macOS ecosystem wins when multiple projects explore this category — each pushes the other forward.

FAQ: picking a notch app

Is NotchIA a fork of Boring Notch?

No. NotchIA is an independent macOS application developed by Axel Courty and rebuilt from scratch in Swift / SwiftUI. It shares the same category (notch utility) as Boring Notch but does not derive from its codebase. The two projects are distinct, with different teams, business models and feature sets.

Are Boring Notch and NotchIA competitors?

They are in the same category (macOS notch utility) but not strictly competitors. Boring Notch targets an open-source audience that wants a free, community-driven experience. NotchIA targets users who want polished UX, live AI (Claude Code, Codex, Copilot) and on-device Apple Intelligence. Both can coexist depending on priorities.

Which one to choose for the MacBook notch?

Choose Boring Notch if you want 100% free, open-source, no telemetry, hackable. Choose NotchIA if you want 14 native modules, live integration of developer AI tools (Claude Code, ChatGPT Codex, GitHub Copilot), Apple Intelligence Digest on-device, and a 4-language interface.

Can I install Boring Notch and NotchIA at the same time?

Technically, yes — but it is not recommended: both apps take control of the notch zone, which produces visual conflicts and duplicate system HUDs. Picking one and testing it for two weeks before optionally switching to the other is more effective.

Does NotchIA work on MacBooks without a notch?

Yes. On Macs without a physical notch (MacBook Air M1, Mac Mini, iMac, Mac Studio), NotchIA renders its interface in the menu bar, emulating a notch zone. Most modules (Media, Calendar, Focus, Digest, live AI) work identically.

Which app is best for Claude Code and ChatGPT Codex?

NotchIA is currently the only macOS notch app that displays the live status of Claude Code, ChatGPT Codex and GitHub Copilot in the notch, with 10 states (Compiling, Terminal, Searching, Reading, Writing, etc.) and token usage tracking. Boring Notch does not offer this module.

← All articles